| Platinum | Tazza Kitchen |
| Gold | Dano's Pizza |
| Silver | Schiano's |
| Bronze | Schiano's Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Blue Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hunter-Gatherer Brewery & Alehouse |
| Top Pick | Mellow Mushroom Columbia |
| Top Pick | Nick's House of Pizza Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria and Pub |